8 Best Insoles for Dress Shoes: Comfort & Support in 2024

The best insoles for dress shoes will help you put your best foot forward with a comfortable, supportive design. Gone are the days of foot fatigue, low arches, and rigid leather soles. The inserts on this list drive all-day contentment in even the most traditionally unforgiving shoes.

However, not all men’s dress shoe inserts are created equal. They come in all shapes, sizes, materials, and designs, outfitted with various unique features that address a plethora of ailments. It can be hard to determine which pairs are worth your while, but this is where we come in with eight options that our team has tried and tested.

Whether you need more structure in the shoe or a plusher base to stride on, these are the top choices for dress shoe inserts to ensure that your feet are free from foot pain at your next formal event.

Key Takeaways

After reading way more than I thought I could about insoles, my picks are in. Although there is no shortage of men’s dress shoe inserts, the best insoles for dress shoes are the Happystep Memory Foam option. This supportive design doesn’t take up too much space in the shoe while delivering heaps of comfort for a budget price.

If you prefer a simple foam insert, then the LTOHOE Memory Foam Insoles mold to the foot with a low profile design, perfect for dress shoes like loafers. They’re also under $10.

Why they’re great: Unlike many pairs of insoles, this option has complete memory foam cushioning from toe to heel, making it one of the most comfortable options available. They’re designed to support various orthopedic ailments, from plantar fasciitis to low arches and beyond.

With just enough structure without being rigid, these insoles are a foolproof choice for dress shoes if you spend a lot of time on your feet or simply need more support.

Who are these for? Choose these insoles if you’re looking primarily for support. Perhaps you’ve tried other inflexible insoles that don’t cut it in the comfort department. These offer an impeccable balance between stiff plastic inserts and flimsy foam options, especially if you’re working with flat-bottomed dress shoes or need insoles for work boots.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: If you’re expecting a super plush feeling, then these insoles are likely to disappoint.

Material: Memory foam | Sizes: US 6–8, 8–12 | Color: Grey/Black, Grey/Yellow | Benefit: Arch & plantar fasciitis support

Why they’re great: For supreme comfort minus the bulky design, you’ll make good use of these budget-friendly insoles, especially if you seek a plush upgrade for your footwear. They have an unobtrusive design made from memory foam that’s easy to cut down to your shoe size and are packed with carbon to neutralize odors.

Although they’re pretty much as low-tech as they come, these are the best insoles if you’re looking for a no-fuss, affordable solution to uncomfortable footwear.

Who are these for? If your dress shoes need only a little enhancement, these are the best insoles to choose from. They skip the cumbersome gel construction and keep it simple without crowding the shoes.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: The 8mm-insole option might be a bit thick for some dress shoes, like loafers, causing your instep to touch the top of the shoe. And although they certainly help to reduce foot pain, they don’t provide much support.

Material: Memory foam | Sizes: US 8–13 | Color: 6 | Benefit: Cushion

Why they’re great: As a sleek, low-profile option, these are some of the top insoles for dress shoes if you want them to blend seamlessly with nicer footwear. What makes these insoles unique is that they have small treads on the heel to lift and support. When coupled with the memory foam that molds to the foot, these are lifesavers for relieving uncomfortable foot pressure.

Who are these for? Maybe you don’t need much arch support but are craving more comfortable formal attire… If so, these are the top choices for dress shoe inserts. Wear them in loafers, boat shoes, or derbies – the design cups the heel and administers support through to the toes for long-wearing comfort.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: These insoles deliver only minimal arch support but maintain a high degree of thickness.

Material: Memory foam, plastic | Sizes: US 2.5–15 | Color: Copper | Benefit: Arch & heel support

Why they’re great: For a squishy underfoot feeling, these are the insoles for dress shoes, especially if you’re looking to strike a middle ground between foam and gel. The inner layer is cushioned with bubbles from toe to heel, and the top is decked out with arch support and a contoured heel design.

Finished with odor-neutralizing technology, these dress shoe inserts will make you the most comfortable man at any function.

Who are these for? If you’re seeking a thicker insole, this double-layered design is well-loved as one of the most comfortable men’s dress shoe inserts. They can also be trimmed down for a personalized fit.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: The draw to these insoles is that they soften the impact of harder shoes. However, they don’t offer too much structured support. You may start experiencing foot fatigue after standing for 2+ hours.

Material: Foam (bubbles) | Sizes: US 8–14 | Color: Blue | Benefit: Arch support, cushion, anti-odor

Why they’re great: These sculpted insoles are the best option if you’re looking for more support in rigid, flat dress shoes. Following the natural form of the foot, these insoles act as a mattress, providing ample cushion for feet through a contoured, arched design. They have a bit more structure than pure foam insoles to keep you comfortable, even if you’re looking for the best insoles for standing all day.

Who are these for? If you’re seeking only mild support and structure, then these are the insoles to choose. They’re not overly thick, so you won’t feel like you’re walking on a cloud, but they certainly beat the run-of-the-mill soles of dress shoes, especially because you can cut them down for a perfectly customizable fit.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: Some people expecting more plush support were disappointed by these insoles, mainly because they’re slightly inflexible towards the heel.

Material: Foam | Sizes: US 2.5–17 | Color: Olive | Benefit: Cushion, anti-fatigue

Why they’re great: If you spend a lot of time on your feet for work, then these are the top insoles for dress shoes, especially when it comes to commuting or covering plenty of ground during your day. Created to mitigate foot fatigue, these insoles are designed to help boost your energy throughout the day with fixed arch support and a cushioned heel to absorb shock.

Who are these for? Any guy rocking flat feet can benefit from a pair of these insoles. Given their structured design, they’re especially handy if you’re seeking upgraded arch support for any pair of shoes (think insoles for Converse or insoles for Vans).

Flaws but not deal-breakers: The arch on these insoles may be a bit high for some types of dress shoes, like loafers. If the top of your footwear is a bit low, then you might have difficulty getting your foot into the shoe when the insoles are in place.

Material: PU foam | Sizes: US 4.5–14.5 | Color: Red/black | Benefit: Plantar fasciitis relief, arch support, shock absorbing

Why they’re great: Although most dress shoes already have leather soles, you’ll be hard-pressed to find a pair as comfortable as this replacement. As standout men’s dress shoe inserts, this option matches the high-end feel of your nicest footwear while providing some much-needed foam padding.

They’re also one of the thinnest choices compared to other dress shoe inserts, making them well-suited to various styles, from low-sitting loafers to tight-fitting monk straps that may not accommodate bulkier insoles.

Who are these for? These aren’t the thickest insoles around, but thanks to the carbon filter, they’re stellar for any man seeking to reduce the stink in his dress shoes.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: These insoles have mild foam cushioning built into them, but their primary purpose is to reduce shoe odors rather than provide support.

Material: Lambskin leather | Sizes: US 7–15 | Color: Tan | Benefit: Anti-odor, light cushioning

Why they’re great: These insoles provide a medium degree of arch support, so you can slip them into your dress shoes and never suffer at a function again. They work well for flat feet and plantar fasciitis, and in addition to support, they challenge strong odors and reduce the impact of walking from the foam base and gel construction.

Who are these for? If your feet tire out quickly or you suffer from leg or back pain after a long period of standing, then these insoles are perfect, especially in dress shoes that lack arch support. Rather than limping around the board room, you can feel your best with these insoles.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: These insoles for dress shoes are loaded with support but aren’t the most cushioned, which is worth considering while you weigh different options.

Material: PU foam, gel | Sizes: US 4–15.5 | Color: Blue | Benefit: Cushion, shock absorption, light arch support

Buying Considerations for the Best Insoles For Dress Shoes

Support

Since dress shoes are notoriously flat, most men seeking insoles are in need of an extra dose of support. Support for insoles generally shines through a cradled heel to soften the impact of each step, along with arch support or a raised middle to follow the natural shape of the foot.

Together, these dual enhancements can turn any flat footwear into comfortable dress shoes that will carry you through every day (and all your events) without an ounce of foot fatigue.

Comfort

Aside from support, dress shoe insoles are often used to increase the footwear’s comfort. This is normally thanks to a hefty dose of either PU or memory foam, which molds to the foot for a wholly personalized fit. The foam also softens impact from walking and standing all day and acts as a much welcome replacement for stiff leather insoles that normally accompany dress shoes.

For extra cushion, choose a thicker pair of dress shoe insoles (8mm is normally plenty plush) to further drive comfort. Otherwise, 6mm is normally the perfect sweet spot. Regardless of your choice, just ensure that any thickness you choose is compatible with your chosen footwear.

Lower-profile shoes like loafers may have a harder time accommodating a bulkier insole, ultimately leading them to be less comfortable than without the insert.

Material

Finally, the material is a prime consideration because it reinforces the support, comfort, and moldability of any inserts. Generally speaking, you’ll find gel or foam insoles for dress shoes. Gel insoles feel springy underfoot and are often accompanied by some sort of structured piece to give them form. Gel insoles are a more high-end option and typically come with a price tag to match. They also tend to be bulkier than the alternative.

On the other hand, foam insoles are another popular option with a slim, low-cost design. You may find that foam insoles have less structure than gel options but fit better in most dress shoes due to their thinner form.

Foam insoles are the best option if you simply hope to make your dress shoes more comfortable but may not need features like heavy arch support or lots of impact protection. Additionally, almost all foam inserts can be cut down to fit the shoe exactly, whereas gel often cannot.

How We Chose

As someone with high arches who spends much time on their feet, I keenly understand the importance of quality insoles. Combining my personal experience with the best insoles for dress shoes with some top-rated options, I chose the products on this list based on the following criteria:

Insole Quality: The most important aspect when choosing the best men’s dress shoe inserts is their quality. Not all insoles are made equal, and the options on this list were chosen for their unquestionable condition and ability to hold up over time.

Customer Reviews: Although I’ve tried plenty of pairs of insoles myself, I relied heavily on user reviews to choose the best options. All of the dress shoe inserts on this list are backed by real customers who have benefited from their support and comfort.

Brand Reputation: A lot of insoles for dress shoes come from reputable brands that take pride in quality products. Companies like Dr. Scholl’s and New Balance were included because they are front-runners in the shoe comfort game.

Price: Finally, price factored into the choice because insoles should be accessible to every gentleman. The options on this list span price points, so there should be something for all budgets.

Why Trust Us?

Jane is a long-time men’s fashion writer who has an affinity for all things fancy comfort. This article about the best insoles for dress shoes strives to lead gentlemen in the right direction when it comes to upgrading their footwear to work for them rather than against them.

Backed by her recent articles like most comfortable shoes and best socks for loafers, Jane spends her free time helping guys feel as good as they look through her product recommendations.

Jane’s approach to reviewing insoles for dress shoes follows the same rigorous standards. She researches extensively, consulting industry experts and testing products to provide reliable recommendations. Her commitment to providing trustworthy and informed advice makes her a valuable resource for anyone looking to enhance their wardrobe with the best grooming and fashion products available.

Final Verdict

Out of all the best insoles for dress shoes, the top pick is the Happystep Memory Foam Insoles, which offer a high degree of support minus the cumbersome design. If you prefer a more plush option, the LTOHOE Memory Foam Insoles form to the feet for a completely personalized fit at a compelling budget price.